Empire vs. Empire

I was wondering who would win, the Star Wars Empire, or the Warhammer 40k Imperium of Man?

Let's say in both a battle of fleets of equal tonnage and in an all-out war.

Has this already been discussed?

There have been many discussions regarding this topic... here is one example of how a discussion went....

Spoiler:

Fabricator-General Norse wrote:

There have been many discussions regarding this topic... here is one example of how a discussion went....

Spoiler:

Ah, the pleasure of seeing morons throw about super weapons like candy and conveniently forgetting any cost or limit associated with said super weapons.

I guess it's balanced when the game's villain is defeatable yet powerful enough to challenge . Best way to check it out is to make an ultimate RTS with all of them. The Freespace homeworld mod is well balanced with the original in-game factions and serves a good example ... everyone has advantages and disadvantages. When I saw how easily my GTD Orion Class Destroyer cut in pieces a Hiigaran battlecruiser I let my guard down which resulted in the destruction of my other Orion Class Destroyer by two other battlecruisers , which had 10,000 lives on board. Turned out the cost and time it takes me to produce one Orion Destroyer is bigger than the battlecruiser, meaning he had much more of them. They are also much more mobile and can strike unexpectedly. On the other side in 1v1 my cap-ships win most battles .

Anyway if it is ever going to happen I'm taking on you Pat with my Freespace fleet .

Which Empire? Sidious's, Revan's, Malgus's, Krayt's, Naga Sadow's, the Great Galactic War one, or the Brotherhood of Darkness? Those are the Sith Empires. There's also Xim's Empire, the Rakatan Infinite Empire, the Empire of the Hand, the Fel Empire, and a bunch of others. I'm guessing you mean Sidious's, as that's the only one a lot of you have ever heard of.

Commander Trauma wrote:

Which Empire? Sidious's, Revan's, Malgus's, Krayt's, Naga Sadow's, the Great Galactic War one, or the Brotherhood of Darkness? Those are the Sith Empires. There's also Xim's Empire, the Rakatan Infinite Empire, the Empire of the Hand, the Fel Empire, and a bunch of others. I'm guessing you mean Sidious's, as that's the only one a lot of you have ever heard of.

Does each of those empires has a Star Wars movie ? They know there is such a thing as overuse right ?

Commander Trauma wrote:

Which Empire? Sidious's, Revan's, Malgus's, Krayt's, Naga Sadow's, the Great Galactic War one, or the Brotherhood of Darkness? Those are the Sith Empires. There's also Xim's Empire, the Rakatan Infinite Empire, the Empire of the Hand, the Fel Empire, and a bunch of others. I'm guessing you mean Sidious's, as that's the only one a lot of you have ever heard of.

oooooo nerd burn.

It's called novel's. I know the Youth today has never heard of these forms of LIT-ER-A-TURE, but they're an ancient form of entertainment used by your forefathers in place of CGI space ships and piss poor prequels.

Quote :

Anyway if it is ever going to happen I'm taking on you Pat with my Freespace fleet Smile .

You do realize fleets sent against me usually end up as a scrapyard?

Pat Best wrote:

Quote :

Anyway if it is ever going to happen I'm taking on you Pat with my Freespace fleet Smile .

You do realize fleets sent against me usually end up as a scrapyard?

That's why I take on you .

eazymc wrote:

Commander Trauma wrote:

Which Empire? Sidious's, Revan's, Malgus's, Krayt's, Naga Sadow's, the Great Galactic War one, or the Brotherhood of Darkness? Those are the Sith Empires. There's also Xim's Empire, the Rakatan Infinite Empire, the Empire of the Hand, the Fel Empire, and a bunch of others. I'm guessing you mean Sidious's, as that's the only one a lot of you have ever heard of.

oooooo nerd burn.

It's called novel's. I know the Youth today has never heard of these forms of LIT-ER-A-TURE, but they're an ancient form of entertainment used by your forefathers in place of CGI space ships and piss poor prequels.

I am offended.
I actually like reading books, they are very entertaining.

eazymc wrote:

Commander Trauma wrote:

Which Empire? Sidious's, Revan's, Malgus's, Krayt's, Naga Sadow's, the Great Galactic War one, or the Brotherhood of Darkness? Those are the Sith Empires. There's also Xim's Empire, the Rakatan Infinite Empire, the Empire of the Hand, the Fel Empire, and a bunch of others. I'm guessing you mean Sidious's, as that's the only one a lot of you have ever heard of.

oooooo nerd burn.

It's called novel's. I know the Youth today has never heard of these forms of LIT-ER-A-TURE, but they're an ancient form of entertainment used by your forefathers in place of CGI space ships and piss poor prequels.

*They're called novels

Sorry. That bugs me.

And no, none of the others have had movies. Several of them have had video games, some others have had comic books, and the rest are novels.

I forgot the Sith Triumvirate and the Mandalorian Empire.

And yes, Star Wars is notorious for plot overuse.

Every single era has the exact same elements. Some evil Empire.

Hell, the entirety of the Infinities timeline is a complete repeat of the trilogy!

MISLEADING BIRD wrote:

And yes, Star Wars is notorious for plot overuse.

Every single era has the exact same elements. Some evil Empire.

Hell, the entirety of the Infinities timeline is a complete repeat of the trilogy!

Uhh. The Infinities is an alternative history of the Galactic Civil War. Of course it has similarities (It's the same characters, at the same time, in the same place...), but it's not the same story. It's also not canon.

Commander Trauma wrote:

MISLEADING BIRD wrote:

And yes, Star Wars is notorious for plot overuse.

Every single era has the exact same elements. Some evil Empire.

Hell, the entirety of the Infinities timeline is a complete repeat of the trilogy!

Uhh. The Infinities is an alternative history of the Galactic Civil War. Of course it has similarities (It's the same characters, at the same time, in the same place...), but it's not the same story. It's also not canon.

Not Infinities infinities, but Infinities. Or Infinity. Idk. It follows the story of Skywalker's son's son's son and is basically the exact same thing as the GCW with some Old Republic Jedi thrown in (that are for some reason still alive..?)

Ah, sorry, the series is called 'Legacy'. Not Infinities.

Strategion Daynel wrote:

eazymc wrote:

Commander Trauma wrote:

Which Empire? Sidious's, Revan's, Malgus's, Krayt's, Naga Sadow's, the Great Galactic War one, or the Brotherhood of Darkness? Those are the Sith Empires. There's also Xim's Empire, the Rakatan Infinite Empire, the Empire of the Hand, the Fel Empire, and a bunch of others. I'm guessing you mean Sidious's, as that's the only one a lot of you have ever heard of.

oooooo nerd burn.

It's called novel's. I know the Youth today has never heard of these forms of LIT-ER-A-TURE, but they're an ancient form of entertainment used by your forefathers in place of CGI space ships and piss poor prequels.

I am offended.
I actually like reading books, they are very entertaining.

I'd be sorry I offended you if I intended it as an offence to those who read. The last part of that comment ("in place of CGI space ships and piss poor prequels") was a jab at people who only watch movies and do not actually understand the lore behind anything that hollywood produces.

I agree about books, though I've shifted from hardbacks to using digital books, however, I do have a few hardbacks still laying around.

Commander Trauma wrote:

*They're called novels

Should change your (muhuhaha) name to grammar Nazi.

Trying really hard not to post something mean.

Seems odd that you would comment on the part of the sentence which was correct, while missing the lack of subject.

Grammar Nazi #2 wrote:

fr0stbyte124 wrote:

Seems odd that you would comment on the part of the sentence that was correct, while missing the lack of subject.

Sea, Tiel, the problem is that your going all crazy at this Grammar Nazi thing. Thats not an good idea. Itll make you to sensitive to little detail's, like miss spelled word's or miner punctuation error's.

Grammar Nazi wrote:

Grammar Nazi #2 wrote:

fr0stbyte124 wrote:

Seems odd that you would comment on the part of the sentence that was correct, while missing the lack of subject.

See, Tiel, the problem is that you're going all crazy with this Grammar Nazi thing. That's not an good idea, it'll make you too sensitive to little details like misspelled words, or minor punctuation errors.

I'm only holding the fort down.

Grammar Nazi #2 wrote:

Grammar Nazi wrote:

Grammar Nazi #2 wrote:

fr0stbyte124 wrote:

Seems odd that you would comment on the part of the sentence that was correct, while missing the lack of subject.

See, Tiel, the problem is that you're going all crazy with this Grammar Nazi thing. That's not an good idea, it'll make you too sensitive to little details like misspelled words, or minor punctuation errors.

I'm only holding the fort down.

This is because you are currently residing in an inflatable hover-fort, and without your weight it would float away?

Tiel, this is your second warning on harrasing others about grammer and spelling and such. The next violation is a ban. I am completely serious on this matter.

Professor Fenway wrote:

Tiel, this is your second warning concerning harrasing others about grammer, spelling and such. The next violation is a ban. I am entirely serious on this matter.

Make it permanent, please.

Also, don't change my profile pic/name. I'd like this account to be remembered as the first (and maybe only) to reach 3k posts.